How to Choose the Right Hurricane Shutter Material: Aluminum vs. Steel

hurricane shutter

Share This Post

When it comes to investing in hurricane shutters for your Fort Myers home, choosing the right material is a crucial decision. With various options available, such as aluminum, steel, wood, and vinyl, understanding the pros and cons of each material is essential in determining the best option for your home’s storm protection needs.

Both aluminum and steel hurricane shutters offer distinct advantages in terms of strength, durability, and resistance to severe weather conditions. However, they also come with their particular drawbacks, such as cost, maintenance, and potential corrosion concerns. Our objective is to help you make an informed choice by providing a comprehensive comparison of these materials, considering factors such as strength, weight, resistance to corrosion, cost, ease of installation, and maintenance.

We understand that protecting your home, family, and assets during storm season is a top priority for any homeowner in Fort Myers. So, we’ll delve into the key aspects of aluminum and steel hurricane shutters, ensuring you have the necessary information and confidence to make the right decision.

In this in-depth guide, you’ll not only learn about the features and benefits of aluminum and steel shutters, but also gain insights on how to decide which material best meets your requirements and aligns with your home’s specific storm-protection needs. Armed with this knowledge, you can decide on the right material for your new hurricane shutters, ensuring your home is well-protected from the harsh elements of Florida’s hurricane season.

Strength and Durability: Standing Up to the Wind

The primary objective of hurricane shutters is to provide reliable and resilient protection against high winds, flying debris, and other storm-related hazards. Both aluminum and steel excel in this department, but there are some differences worth noting:

  1. Aluminum Shutters: Aluminum shutters possess high tensile strength, making them strong and sturdy enough to withstand hurricane-force winds. They are typically designed as roll-down, accordion, Bahama, and colonial shutters. High-quality aluminum shutters are engineered to meet stringent building codes and wind-resistance specifications.
  1. Steel Shutters: Steel shutters offer enhanced strength compared to aluminum counterparts, potentially providing even greater security in extreme weather conditions. However, steel shutters are often thicker and heavier, which can lead to increased installation and labor costs. Steel shutters are commonly available as roll-down and accordion styles.

Weight and Ease of Installation: Simplicity Matters

One significant factor to consider when choosing between aluminum and steel hurricane shutters is their weight and ease of installation:

  1. Aluminum Shutters: Due to their relatively lightweight nature, aluminum shutters are generally easier to install than steel options. This makes aluminum shutters a more appealing choice for DIY enthusiasts or homeowners with limited construction experience. Additionally, the lighter weight means less potential strain on your home’s structure.
  1. Steel Shutters: Steel shutters are notably heavier than aluminum variants, which can make installation more challenging and time-consuming. It may be necessary to enlist professional assistance for proper installation, resulting in increased labor expenses.

Resistance to Corrosion: Taking the Florida Climate Into Account

As a homeowner in Fort Myers, you’re well aware of the corrosive effects of salt, humidity, and moisture. Therefore, it’s essential to choose hurricane shutter materials that can withstand the coastal environment:

  1. Aluminum Shutters: Aluminum is naturally resistant to corrosion, making it an attractive choice for homes located in coastal areas. High-quality aluminum shutters often come with a durable powder-coated finish, further enhancing their corrosion protection. Nonetheless, regular maintenance and cleaning are still necessary to maintain their appearance and performance.
  1. Steel Shutters: Steel shutters can be vulnerable to rust and corrosion, particularly in humid, salt-laden environments. To combat this issue, steel shutters are typically galvanized and coated with a high-quality paint or finish. While these treatments substantially improve steel shutters’ corrosion resistance, vigilant maintenance is essential to prevent rust and damage.

Cost and Longevity: Balancing Initial Investment and Long-Term Value

The cost of hurricane shutters is a vital consideration for most homeowners, and it’s important to find a balance between initial investment and long-term value:

  1. Aluminum Shutters: Aluminum shutters are generally more affordable than steel counterparts, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners. Their lightweight nature can also result in lower installation costs. Additionally, aluminum shutters offer impressive longevity, provided they’re adequately maintained and cleaned.
  1. Steel Shutters: Steel shutters can be more expensive than aluminum options due to the material’s increased strength and durability. Furthermore, installation costs may be higher due to the heavier weight of steel shutters. Despite their potential for corrosion, when adequately cared for, steel shutters can provide decades of reliable protection.

Choosing the Perfect Material for Your Hurricane Shutters

When deciding between aluminum and steel hurricane shutters, consider the following factors to make an informed decision:

  1. Your location and storm risk: Properties in coastal areas or those more susceptible to hurricanes may require the superior strength of steel shutters. Alternatively, aluminum shutters may suffice for homes situated further inland or with less exposure to severe weather conditions.
  1. Your budget: While aluminum shutters tend to be more affordable upfront, consider the potential long-term costs, such as increased maintenance for steel shutters or replacement costs for damaged or corroded shutters. Factor in the costs of professional installation, if required.
  1. Home aesthetics: Consider your preferences in terms of shutter style, color, and finish. Available aluminum and steel shutter styles may vary, with aluminum offering a wider range of options, including Bahama and colonial shutters.
  1. Maintenance requirements: If you prefer a low-maintenance solution, aluminum shutters may be the better choice, but proper cleaning and routine inspections should still be performed. Steel shutters require diligent maintenance to ensure rust and corrosion remain at bay.

Find the Right Material for Your Home and Needs

Choosing the ideal hurricane shutter material for your Fort Myers home is a decision not to be taken lightly. Weighing the pros and cons of aluminum and steel options while considering your location, budget, installation requirements, and maintenance preferences will help you arrive at a well-informed decision.

Whichever material you select, be confident that your investment in high-quality hurricane shutters will provide you with lasting storm protection and peace of mind.

Contact Hurricane Shutter Company Fort Myers today for more information on the best hurricane shutters!

More To Explore