Comparing Hurricane Shutter Materials: Which One Is Best for Your Fort Myers Home?

hurricane shutter

Share This Post

Living in Fort Myers means facing hurricane season every year, and taking proactive measures to protect your home from potential damage is crucial. One essential protective measure is installing hurricane shutters, which can shield your windows and doors from high winds, flying debris, and torrential rains. 

However, with a wide array of available materials, it can be challenging to determine which type of hurricane shutter is the best fit for your home. Although all shutters are designed to provide storm protection, each material comes with its unique advantages and drawbacks that can significantly affect the overall performance, durability, and cost of your shutters.

In this in-depth article, we will explore the most common materials used in hurricane shutter production, including aluminum, steel, and polycarbonate. By evaluating the pros and cons of each material, we aim to provide you with the necessary information to make an informed decision when choosing your hurricane shutters. 

Our comparison will cover crucial factors such as material strength, durability, weight, corrosion resistance, maintenance requirements, and price, allowing you to weigh your options and select the one that best suits your needs and budget.

Your choice of hurricane shutter material can have a long-lasting impact on the safety and structural integrity of your Fort Myers home during hurricane season. By educating yourself about the different materials and their associated benefits and drawbacks, you will be better equipped to make an informed decision, ensuring that your home receives the optimal protection it deserves. 

Read on to learn all about the characteristics of these popular hurricane shutter materials and their suitability for various applications in your home.

Aluminum Hurricane Shutters: Lightweight and Durable

Aluminum is one of the most popular materials used for hurricane shutters due to its combination of strength, lightweight properties, and resistance to corrosion. Let’s take a closer look at the advantages and drawbacks of aluminum shutters:


– Lightweight: Hurricane Shutter Company Fort Myers aluminum shutters are lighter than steel and wood, making them easier to install and operate.

– Durability: Aluminum offers excellent corrosion resistance, ensuring that your shutters will last for many years without rusting.

– Low maintenance: Aluminum shutters require minimal maintenance and can withstand harsh weather conditions without needing regular painting or sealing.


– Cost: Hurricane Shutter Company Fort Myers aluminum shutters are generally more expensive than other shutter materials, but their durability and low maintenance may justify the higher initial investment.

– Strength: While aluminum is strong enough to resist hurricane-force winds, it may not be as robust as steel shutters.

Steel Hurricane Shutters: Strength and Affordability

Steel Hurricane Shutter Company Fort Myers offers strength and security at a lower price point than aluminum. Here’s a rundown of the pros and cons of choosing steel shutters for your home:


– Strength: Steel is one of the strongest materials available for hurricane shutters, providing excellent protection against flying debris and extreme winds.

– Affordability: Steel shutters are generally less expensive than aluminum shutters, making them a more cost-effective option for budget-conscious homeowners.

– Versatility: Steel shutters can be used for various applications, including permanent mounting and removable storm panels.


– Weight: Steel shutters are heavier than aluminum, which can make them more challenging to install and operate.

– Corrosion resistance: While galvanized steel offers some protection against rust and corrosion, it may not be as resistant as aluminum or other non-metallic materials like polycarbonate.

– Maintenance: Steel shutters require regular maintenance, such as painting and sealing, to prevent rust and decrease their lifespan.

Polycarbonate Hurricane Shutters: Transparency and Impact Resistance

Polycarbonate is a type of clear, impact-resistant plastic that offers unique advantages over traditional metal shutters. Check out the pros and cons of polycarbonate shutters:


– Transparency: Polycarbonate shutters are transparent, allowing natural light into your home during a storm and eliminating the need for artificial lighting.

– Impact resistance: Polycarbonate is virtually unbreakable and can withstand extreme winds and flying debris without cracking or shattering.

– Corrosion resistance: Unlike metal shutters, polycarbonate does not rust or corrode, making it an excellent option for homes in coastal areas.


– Cost: Polycarbonate shutters are generally more expensive than steel shutters, but their unique features may justify the additional investment.

– UV resistance: Although many polycarbonate panels are treated with a UV-resistant coating, prolonged exposure to sunlight can cause the material to become discolored or brittle over time.

– Scratching: Polycarbonate is prone to scratching, which can affect the shutter’s appearance and visibility. However, some manufacturers offer scratch-resistant coatings to address this issue.

Comparing Hurricane Shutter Materials: Making the Right Choice

When selecting the best hurricane shutter material for your Fort Myers home, consider the following factors:

– Strength: Assess the strength of each material and its ability to withstand hurricane-force winds and flying debris.

– Weight: Consider the weight of the shutters, as heavier materials may be more difficult to install and operate.

– Resistance to corrosion: Determine the corrosion resistance of each material, especially important in coastal areas where saltwater and humidity are present.

– Price: Evaluate the cost of each material, including installation and maintenance expenses, to find a solution that fits within your budget.

– Aesthetic appeal: Consider the visual appeal of the shutters, as they will be a permanent addition to the exterior of your home.

– Maintenance: Assess the maintenance requirements of each material and whether you are willing to commit to regular upkeep.

Weighing Your Options for the Ultimate Protection

Selecting the right hurricane shutter material for your Fort Myers home is a crucial decision that requires careful consideration of various factors. By comparing the strengths and drawbacks of aluminum, steel, and polycarbonate shutters, you can make an informed choice that best meets your needs, budget, and aesthetic preferences.

Ultimately, the most critical aspect of hurricane shutters is their ability to provide adequate protection for your home. Whichever material you choose, ensure that the shutters are of high quality and professionally installed to give you peace of mind during hurricane season. For more details about hurricane shutters in Fort Myers, contact Hurricane Shutter Company Fort Myers today!

More To Explore